In the case at hand, "person A" would be heavenly Getchen, and "person B" earthly Gretchen. So according to Miller, heavenly Gretchen would be the same person as earthly Gretchen if and only if …

I can see who I am talking to." (p. 12) Sam is reasoning as follows: if you are Gretchen Weinrob, that means (given premise one) that you possess a particular soul (the one that is responsible for …

Weinrob: person can remember fake memories, things they didn't experience or can forget memories; "same person" doesn't garuntee "same memories" - Cohen argues the diff between fake memories …

The trouble is that you couldn’t know whether your original brain has actually been transplanted into another person’s body, or whether the brain you now have has been rejuvenated with another …

Person #2 would certainly believe she (or he) is the real Weirob, but the thought-experiment argument shows Person #2 simply cannot be the real Weirob. This is why Weirob refuses the surgery she has …

Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like In John Perry's A Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality, Gretchen Weirob claims that a proponent of the immaterial soul …

Gretchen Wieners is one of the main characters in Mean Girls. She is portrayed by Lacey Chabert in the movie, and Ashley Park in the musical. Gretchen is a member of the Plastics. She is the gossip girl in …

Miller and Weirob who argued who the new person would be if Julia’s brain was implanted into Mary’s body. Miller thinks it would be Julia because her soul or the memory is being transferred into Mary’s …

Gretchen Weirob – philosophy prof, atheist, materialist, empiricist, skeptic; is dying from injuries sustained in a motorcycle accident Sam Miller – professional chaplain (presumably Christian) and a …

In the First Night of John Perry’s paper, “A Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality”, Perry introduces us to Gretchen Weirob, a teacher of philosophy who was hospitalized due to injuries that …